Pipeline Stability Compare Report

目录位置：share/pipeline_stability_2026-04-14/

样本数：10

无差异素材：7

有差异素材：3

核心字段完全稳定：6/8

整体稳定性摘要

business.relevance 两轮一致：10/10
8 个核心字段里，完全一致的有 6 个。
主要波动集中在 subject.primary_scene_type（7/10）和 visual.primary_element（9/10）。
分享访问时可直接打开本页，再点击素材链接查看原图/视频。

Run1: /Users/russell/.openclaw/workspace/share/pipeline_stability_2026-04-14/run1/e2e_20260414_114041/labeled_results.json
Run2: /Users/russell/.openclaw/workspace/share/pipeline_stability_2026-04-14/run2/e2e_20260414_114238/labeled_results.json

字段稳定性

Field	一致数	一致率
business.relevance	10/10	100%
copy.hook_type	10/10	100%
copy.cta_style	10/10	100%
visual.primary_element	9/10	90%
subject.primary_scene_type	7/10	70%
platform_style.native_feel	10/10	100%
offer.primary_angle	10/10	100%
structure.delivery_format	10/10	100%

素材目录

7110325753712443393<\/a>7209041858210185217<\/a>7235011099156938753<\/a>7238708101850497025<\/a>7246835211337564161<\/a>meta_1291812169475375<\/a>meta_1317531057058722<\/a>meta_1431535721955123<\/a>meta_2140277223458932<\/a>meta_890760327158441<\/a>

7110325753712443393

video · tiktok_7110325753712443393.mp4

original relevance: loan_related · run1: loan_related · run2: loan_related

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/tiktok_7110325753712443393.mp4

shared file: media_files/tiktok_7110325753712443393.mp4

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_related	loan_related
Hook type	urgency	urgency
CTA style	apply_now	apply_now
Primary element	badge_label	badge_label
Scene type	office	office
Native feel	very_native	very_native
Primary angle	unknown	unknown
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none

7209041858210185217

video · tiktok_7209041858210185217.mp4

original relevance: loan_core · run1: loan_core · run2: loan_core

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/tiktok_7209041858210185217.mp4

shared file: media_files/tiktok_7209041858210185217.mp4

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_core	loan_core
Hook type	urgency	urgency
CTA style	swipe_click	swipe_click
Primary element	none	none
Scene type	street	street
Native feel	very_native	very_native
Primary angle	fast_disbursement	fast_disbursement
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none

7235011099156938753

video · tiktok_7235011099156938753.mp4

original relevance: loan_related · run1: general_finance · run2: general_finance

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/tiktok_7235011099156938753.mp4

shared file: media_files/tiktok_7235011099156938753.mp4

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	general_finance	general_finance
Hook type	question	question
CTA style	apply_now	apply_now
Primary element	form_screen	form_screen
Scene type	home	studio_plain_bg
Native feel	very_native	very_native
Primary angle	unknown	unknown
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs:

subject.primary_scene_type: home → studio_plain_bg

7238708101850497025

video · tiktok_7238708101850497025.mp4

original relevance: loan_related · run1: non_loan · run2: non_loan

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/tiktok_7238708101850497025.mp4

shared file: media_files/tiktok_7238708101850497025.mp4

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	non_loan	non_loan
Hook type	topical_hook	topical_hook
CTA style	learn_more	learn_more
Primary element	badge_label	badge_label
Scene type	vehicle	vehicle
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	unknown	unknown
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none

7246835211337564161

video · tiktok_7246835211337564161.mp4

original relevance: loan_related · run1: non_loan · run2: non_loan

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/tiktok_7246835211337564161.mp4

shared file: media_files/tiktok_7246835211337564161.mp4

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	non_loan	non_loan
Hook type	storytelling	storytelling
CTA style	learn_more	learn_more
Primary element	badge_label	badge_label
Scene type	home	home
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	unknown	unknown
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none

meta_1291812169475375

image · meta_1291812169475375.jpg

original relevance: loan_core · run1: loan_core · run2: loan_core

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/meta_1291812169475375.jpg

shared file: media_files/meta_1291812169475375.jpg

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_core	loan_core
Hook type	direct_offer	direct_offer
CTA style	none	none
Primary element	none	none
Scene type	studio_plain_bg	studio_plain_bg
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	fast_disbursement	fast_disbursement
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none

meta_1317531057058722

image · meta_1317531057058722.jpg

original relevance: loan_related · run1: loan_core · run2: loan_core

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/meta_1317531057058722.jpg

shared file: media_files/meta_1317531057058722.jpg

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_core	loan_core
Hook type	question	question
CTA style	get_cash_now	get_cash_now
Primary element	cash_icon	cash_icon
Scene type	studio_plain_bg	studio_plain_bg
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	easy_approval	easy_approval
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none

meta_1431535721955123

image · meta_1431535721955123.jpg

original relevance: loan_related · run1: loan_related · run2: loan_related

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/meta_1431535721955123.jpg

shared file: media_files/meta_1431535721955123.jpg

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_related	loan_related
Hook type	urgency	urgency
CTA style	learn_more	learn_more
Primary element	none	none
Scene type	unknown	ui_only
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	fast_disbursement	fast_disbursement
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs:

subject.primary_scene_type: unknown → ui_only

meta_2140277223458932

image · meta_2140277223458932.jpg

original relevance: loan_core · run1: loan_related · run2: loan_related

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/meta_2140277223458932.jpg

shared file: media_files/meta_2140277223458932.jpg

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_related	loan_related
Hook type	unknown	unknown
CTA style	download_app	download_app
Primary element	none	phone_mockup
Scene type	unknown	phone_only
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	fully_online	fully_online
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs:

visual.primary_element: none → phone_mockup
subject.primary_scene_type: unknown → phone_only

meta_890760327158441

image · meta_890760327158441.jpg

original relevance: loan_core · run1: loan_core · run2: loan_core

source: /Users/russell/creative-library/raw/2026-03/meta_890760327158441.jpg

shared file: media_files/meta_890760327158441.jpg

Field	Run 1	Run 2
Relevance	loan_core	loan_core
Hook type	urgency	urgency
CTA style	apply_now	apply_now
Primary element	none	none
Scene type	unknown	unknown
Native feel	ad_like	ad_like
Primary angle	fully_online	fully_online
Delivery format	—	—

Detected diffs: none